Bank transfers have become a common payment method in commercial transactions, business activities, and everyday life. However, a minor mistake when entering an account number, selecting a beneficiary, or confirming a transaction may result in money being transferred to the wrong bank account.
In such circumstances, many people are concerned about whether they can recover the transferred amount, particularly when the recipient refuses to cooperate or deliberately declines to return the money.
So, what does Vietnamese law provide regarding the obligation to return money transferred by mistake? What legal consequences may arise if the recipient knowingly refuses to return the money?
1. Can You Recover Money Transferred to the Wrong Bank Account?
Yes. A person who mistakenly transfers money has the right to request that the recipient return the amount received if there is no lawful basis for the recipient to retain it.
Specifically, Article 579 of the 2015 Civil Code provides for the obligation to return property in cases of possession, use, or enrichment without lawful grounds. Accordingly, a person possessing or using another person's property without lawful grounds must return such property to its owner or another person having lawful rights over it.
Furthermore, Article 580 of the 2015 Civil Code stipulates that a person possessing or using property without lawful grounds must return all property obtained.
In addition, Point d, Clause 2, Article 20 of Circular No. 17/2024/TT-NHNN requires payment account holders to return, or cooperate with banks and foreign bank branches in returning, amounts mistakenly or erroneously credited to their payment accounts.
Therefore, the fact that money has been credited to a bank account does not automatically mean that the recipient has acquired lawful ownership of that amount. Once it is established that the money was transferred by mistake and that there is no lawful basis for retaining it, the recipient is obliged to return it.
2. What Are the Legal Consequences if the Recipient Deliberately Refuses to Return the Money?
If the recipient knows that the money was transferred by mistake but deliberately refuses to return it, they may incur administrative, civil, or even criminal liability, depending on the nature and severity of the conduct and the applicable statutory requirements.
2.1. Civil Liability
Pursuant to Articles 579 and 580 of the 2015 Civil Code, a person who receives money transferred by mistake is obliged to return the entire amount received without lawful grounds.
Even if the recipient has used or caused the loss of the money, the obligation to return it may still arise in accordance with applicable law.
If the recipient refuses to voluntarily return the money, the person who made the mistaken transfer may initiate legal proceedings before a competent court to resolve the dispute and protect their lawful rights and interests.
2.2. Administrative Liability
Under Point đ, Clause 2, Article 18 of Decree No. 282/2025/ND-CP, the act of unlawfully retaining another person's property, where the conduct does not warrant criminal prosecution, may be subject to a fine ranging from VND 3,000,000 to VND 5,000,000.
In addition, the violator may be required to return the unlawfully retained property or pay an amount equivalent to the value of the property that has been consumed, dispersed, or destroyed in violation of the law.
2.3. Criminal Liability
Notably, deliberately refusing to return money transferred by mistake may, in certain circumstances, constitute the Crime of Unlawful Appropriation of Property under Article 176 of the 2015 Criminal Code, as amended and supplemented.
Specifically:
- Case 1: The recipient deliberately refuses to return property valued at VND 10,000,000 or more but less than VND 200,000,000 after the owner, lawful manager, or competent authority has requested its return in accordance with the law.
- Case 2: The property is valued at less than VND 10,000,000 but constitutes a relic or antique mistakenly delivered to, or found or recovered by, the recipient, who deliberately refuses to return it after being requested to do so.
- Case 3: The unlawfully retained property is valued at VND 200,000,000 or more, or constitutes a national treasure, falling within the circumstances specified in Clause 2, Article 176 of the Criminal Code.
Accordingly, the offender may be subject to the following penalties:
It should be noted that not every case in which a person receives money transferred by mistake and fails to return it automatically constitutes a criminal offense. Criminal liability must be assessed based on the value of the property, the intentional refusal to return it, the request for its return, and all other statutory elements constituting the offense.
3. What Should You Do to Recover Money Transferred by Mistake?
Upon discovering that a bank transfer has been made to the wrong account, the sender should promptly take the following steps:
Step 1: Immediately contact the bank to request transaction tracing.
The sender should contact the bank where their payment account is maintained or submit a tracing or complaint request through the bank's application.
The request should clearly specify:
- The date and time of the transaction;
- The amount transferred;
- The recipient's account number and account holder's name;
- The transaction description; and
- The reason for requesting transaction tracing.
The sender should ask their bank to coordinate with the beneficiary's bank to verify the transaction and provide guidance on the procedures for recovering the money.
Step 2: Preserve all evidence relating to the transaction.
The sender should retain the transaction receipt, account statements, transfer details, communications with the bank, and any other relevant documents.
These materials constitute important evidence to establish that the transfer was made by mistake and serve as a basis for requesting the recipient to return the money.
Step 3: Send a request for repayment to the recipient (if their identity can be established).
If the recipient can be identified, the sender may issue a written request for repayment, specifying the amount transferred, the date of the mistaken transfer, and the requested repayment deadline.
The request should be sent through a method that allows the sender to retain evidence of its delivery date and contents.
Step 4: Report the matter to the police if there are signs of intentional unlawful retention of property.
If the recipient knows that the money was transferred by mistake but deliberately refuses to return it, avoids contact, or shows signs of using or disposing of the money, the sender may file a report with the competent police authority for receipt, verification, and handling in accordance with the law.
Step 5: Initiate legal proceedings before a competent court.
If the recipient does not voluntarily return the money and the dispute cannot be resolved through other measures, the sender may initiate civil proceedings before a competent court to request the return of property possessed without lawful grounds.
4. Can the Bank Automatically Recover Money Transferred by Mistake?
This is an issue that many people misunderstand when requesting the return of mistakenly transferred funds.
Under Point a, Clause 2, Article 21 of Circular No. 17/2024/TT-NHNN, a bank is entitled to proactively debit a customer's payment account in certain circumstances, including where the bank discovers that an amount has been mistakenly credited to the customer's account, or where the bank receives a request to cancel a credit transfer order from the remitting bank due to discrepancies between the executed payment and the original payment instruction.
However, the following two situations must be distinguished:
- The bank mistakenly credits the recipient's account due to the bank's own error: The bank has grounds to make adjustments and debit the account in accordance with Circular No. 17/2024/TT-NHNN.
- The customer enters incorrect beneficiary information when making the transfer: This does not automatically constitute a circumstance in which the bank is entitled to unilaterally debit the recipient's account. Recovery must instead be carried out through transaction tracing, coordination between the relevant parties, voluntary repayment, or a request from a competent authority, as prescribed by law.
Therefore, although banks play an important role in assisting with transaction tracing, verification, and coordination, not every mistaken bank transfer can be automatically reversed or recovered by the bank.
5. What Should Recipients of Mistaken Bank Transfers Be Aware Of?
Some people believe that once money has been credited to their personal bank account, they have full ownership rights over that amount. However, this understanding is inconsistent with applicable legal provisions.
If a recipient discovers that their account has received an unexplained amount or a potentially mistaken transfer, they should:
- Refrain from withdrawing, transferring, or using the money before its lawful basis has been verified.
- Proactively contact their bank to verify the transaction.
- Cooperate with the bank in returning the amount once it has been confirmed as a mistaken transfer.
- Avoid transferring money directly to strangers at their request by telephone or text message without first verifying the transaction with the bank.
- Retain all documents and information relating to the receipt and return of the money.
In particular, recipients should remain alert to scams involving mistaken bank transfers, in which fraudsters subsequently request that the money be returned to a different account or ask for login credentials or OTP codes.
To minimize potential risks, any repayment should be carried out through the bank's official procedures.
6. Conclusion
A mistaken bank transfer does not mean that the sender automatically loses the right to recover the money. Vietnamese law provides specific rules on the obligation to return property obtained without lawful grounds and establishes legal sanctions for deliberately retaining another person's property.
Accordingly, when a mistaken transfer occurs, the sender should promptly contact the bank, preserve relevant evidence, and take the necessary legal steps to protect their rights and interests. Conversely, the recipient should proactively cooperate in returning the money to avoid unnecessary disputes and potential legal liability.
Disclaimer: This article is provided for general legal information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice in relation to any specific case.









